The Mahalo Top 7
- Metacritic: Samantha Who? Reviews
- Variety: Samantha Who? Review
- Entertainment Weekly: Samantha Who? Preview
- Common Sense Media: Samantha Who? Review for Parents
- Hollywood Reporter: Samantha Who? Review
- SFGate.com: Applegate's charm lost amid lame jokes in Samantha
- YouTube Video: Samantha Who? Season 2 Promo (Time: 0:31)
Samantha Who? Reviews
- Metromix Chicago: Samantha Who? Review (2.5/5)
- "After 30 unexceptional minutes of this show, a little head bump and some amnesia don't seem so bad after all!"
- Buddy TV: Samantha Who? Pilot Review
- " Samantha Who? is a harmless comedy that succeeds thanks to clever writing, solid characters and the comic charm of Christina Applegate."
- Zap2It: Samantha Who? Review
- "Applegate is entirely winning as the bewildered Sam."
- New York Daily News: Samantha Who? Review (2.5/4)
- "Samantha Who?" plays the discovery parts nicely. The question for this show, as it gets a few episodes in, is a trickier one: Once Sam starts recognizing everything and everyone around her, and makes the necessary adjustments, what's left?"
- Newsday.com: Samantha Who? Review
- "Told in sassy single-camera style, this is a self-possessed show that can actually have a character say "Wake up, sleepyhead, you're not in a coma anymore" with effective results."
- LA Weekly: Samantha Who? Review
- "I have no quibble with this well-made, sly, heartwarming and at times giddily funny show."
- New York Post: Who Is It? (2.5/4)
- "The only thing memorable about this new amnesia comedy is the show's star, Christina Applegate."
- USAToday.com: Talent lifts Samantha, But Will Premise Endure?
- "Applegate holds the character together even when she's yelping or collapsing in a dither."
- MiamiHerald.com: You Really Don't Want to Forget to Tune in Tonight
- "It's a winner from the start."
- Los Angeles Times: Remember This Sitcom: Samantha Who?
- "The smart, screwball show makes fine use of Christina Applegate as an amnesiac turning away from her former loathesome self."