Guide Note

"Eleanor Rigby" (originally from The Beatles' album Revolver) was performed by American Idol contestant David Cook on the March 11, 2008, episode. After Cook's performance controversy erupted and rumors began circulating that he had ripped off the band Doxology. However, before his performance he did comment on where he found his arrangement of the song.

Fast Facts

1. Air date: March 11, 2008
2. Network: FOX
3. Theme night: The Beatles

Judges' Comments

Randy said he can definitely rock out on Idol. Started out a little unsafe but once he hit the chorus it was rocking.

Paula said she's been telling everyone he's the dark horse. She thought he was fantastic. She also said he's the frontman here on American Idol.

Simon thought it was brilliant. He said if the show remains a talent competition then he could win the entire show.