Guide Note

American Idol has been plagued by scandals since its first season. This page contains the most current and famous scandals surrounding the popular singing competition television show.

David Hernandez allegedly worked as a dancer at Dick's Cabaret and Burn, both gay strip clubs in Arizona before appearing on American Idol Season 7. The manager of Dick's Cabaret said in an interview that Hernandez worked at his club for three years.

The production company that produces the German version of American Idol was successfully sued for emotional damages by a 17 year old who appeared on the show.

1. Show: Deutschland Sucht Den Superstar
2. Contestant collapsed after audition
3. Received hate mail from fans
4. Settlement 100,000 euros ($147,000)

Many contestants, particularly Carly Smithson, have had previous experience as recording artists in the top 24 of American Idol Season 7. To some people, this seems a breech of the rules of the show. While contestants cannot have a record deal during the show, they are allowed to have previous contracts that have expired or be released from them.

1. Formerly Carly Hennessey
2. Of Irish descent
3. Previous recordings unsuccessful
4. Previous label: MCA Records